Learning from the Bees
A semester in Costa Rica turned a biology student into
a research biologist.

Brendan Borrell sets up artificial "flowers" for
his research on orchid bees' nectar foraging habits |
by Nancy Oster
or
the past three years, evolutionary biologist Brendan Borrell
has been studying the nectar foraging activities of Central
American orchid bees. While most bees use their hairy tongues
to lick the nectar from shallow flowers, Brendan has found
that orchid bees have adapted to consume nectars from deeper
flowers in tropical forests by sucking the nectar out through
their long tubular proboscises (which stretch up to three times
their own body length).
In 1998, Brendan, a biology student at UC Santa Barbara,
chose to spend his fall term in Monteverde, Costa Rica as an
EAP
student. “I had just discovered the photographs of the Monteverde
photographers, Michael and Patricia Fogden in Harry Greene’s
Snakes book,” he says, “and I knew I had to get to the tropics.
Next thing I knew I was picking up an application in the
EAP office.”
Brendan says, “Monteverde had a profound effect on me, changing
my perspective from being someone who was just curious about
science to someone who actually wanted to do science.” In
Monteverde, Brendan did independent research with Dr. Frank
Joyce, the
EAP Study Center Director, on the diversity and abundance
of arachnids along a specific altitudinal gradient. “After
EAP,
my parents were pretty surprised when I told them I was planning
to apply for Ph.D. programs.” Brendan graduated from UC Santa
Barbara with High Honors in 1999.
Monteverde had a profound effect on me, changing my perspective
from being someone who was just curious about science to someone
who actually wanted to do science.
Looking back, Brendan says, “My EAP experience gave me a
chance to get a job as a field assistant in Panama, and I think
both
of those experiences really helped out as I was applying
to graduate school.” He notes, “If you’re thinking about going
to graduate school, I think you have to do some research
first
to see if you really like it. Why wait until you graduate?”
Following EAP, Brendan did research studies on tungara frogs
in Panama, rattlesnakes in Texas, and pteropods in Antarctica.
Brendan is currently working on his Ph.D. in Integrative
Biology at UC Berkeley. When asked how he chose orchid bees
for a dissertation
topic Brendan said, “Like most dissertation topics I discovered
it after a lot of trial and error. During my first field
season, I was struggling with a project on beetles—spending
a lot of
time catching them in front of the black lights I was hauling
all over Costa Rica. One night, an orchid bee (my first orchid
bee) showed up at my black light, which was quite unexpected
because they are day-flying insects. Well, I did what any
good entomologist would do; I killed it with ethyl acetate
and looked
at it under a microscope. The first thing I noticed was its
incredibly long proboscis. When I discovered that nobody
had really studied much about nectar foraging in orchid bees,
I
decided that’s what I wanted to do.”
Brendan adds, “In some sense, my latest project has been
fueled by EAP memories. To measure the various properties of
the nectars
that orchid bees were foraging on in a variety of habitats,
I ended up choosing a number of field sites that I had first
visited with Dr. Joyce—Pitilla, Santa Rosa, Monteverde, and
Penas Blancas. This was great because I already knew the
trails pretty well so I could just throw on a backpack and
head out
to the forest on my own.”
On these treks Brendan collects orchid bees and is able extract
nectar samples from their honey crops. He combines this information
with behavioral studies on captive bees, and laboratory investigations
of the physics of drinking nectar. The Royal Society recently
published a paper Brendan wrote on the results of his orchid
bee fieldwork. Brendan has found that orchid bees can still
drink nectar after their tongues have been removed from their
proboscis, which demonstrates that they do not use their
tongues to lap nectar like other types of bees. He has also
shown that
orchid bees are more efficient drinkers of runnier nectar,
the kind found in the deep funnel-shaped orchids in tropical
forests.
During one of his field site visits to Costa Rica, his younger
sister Allison joined him. Brendan says, “I forced Allison
to go out in the rain and mud to collect insects for me,
and I took her on a pretty grueling trek through Corcovado.”
A year after trekking through the muddy Costa Rican forests
with her brother, Allison went back to Monteverde as an EAP
student to work on her own research project. Brendan says,
“It actually made me a bit jealous when I heard that she
was going.” However, he notes, “The course really opened her
eyes
and made her a lot more independent. Although she’s not necessarily
going to be a gung-ho tropical biologist, I think perhaps
it even had a bigger effect on her than it did on me.”
About his own EAP experience, Brendan says, “The other thing
that has been great has been running into so many EAPers
all over the place, some of whom are now my colleagues: David
Logue
is now studying birds in Panama; my teaching assistant, Alex
Trillo, studies leaf beetles in Panama; and Stacey Combes,
who was in Monteverde the year before me, will be a Miller
Postdoc in our lab in Berkeley this year. Since the program,
I think I’ve run into about ten EAPers who are still doing
tropical biology in some form or another, and I think that’s
great.”
|